[KJ6]≫ PDF Gratis The Greatest Traitor The Life of Sir Roger Mortimer Ruler of England 13271330 IAN MORTIMER 9780224062497 Books

The Greatest Traitor The Life of Sir Roger Mortimer Ruler of England 13271330 IAN MORTIMER 9780224062497 Books

Download As PDF : The Greatest Traitor The Life of Sir Roger Mortimer Ruler of England 13271330 IAN MORTIMER 9780224062497 Books

The Greatest Traitor The Life of Sir Roger Mortimer Ruler of England 13271330 IAN MORTIMER 9780224062497 Books

Most of this work is very nuanced and insightful, as it demonstrates the fluctuations in the relationships between the nobility and Edward II, and that it was not simply a matter of all the lords lining up against Edward II and Gaveston or Edward II and Despenser. The author also presents a great deal of information about English rule I. Ireland in the 1310s and 1320s, a topic that is often glossed over in general discussions of this era in English history.

It loses its course somewhat from its discussion of the Berkeley Castle plot onward, however. While Mortimer presents an interesting case for Edward II's survival that cannot be readily disproven he assumes the ex-King survived based on hypotheticals and without sufficient substantiation, thus affecting his depiction of events from 1327 to 1330. His narrative of events is dependent on the ideas that Edward III knew Edward II survived before the trial of Lord Berkeley, that Edward III wanted vengeance for his father when there is no evidence of strong filial piety prior to joining Queen Isabella and Roger Mortimer in France, and the notion that Roger Mortimer and Isabella had a child when, in spite of the centuries of stories around their "great romance," when even the author presents no concrete evidence that they engaged in a physical relationship.

This is a worthwhile read, but one must be careful to account for the impact of the author's assumptions and interpretations on the overarching evidence-based narrative of the events of the life of Roger Mortimer. We cannot and should not dismiss these biases outright, but the events that occurred in 1327 to 1330 could reasonably have occurred without Edward II's survival, and Edward III's push for Roger Mortimer's end not out of wanting to avenge his father's death or out of the threat posed by his father's continued survival, but simply to be free of Roger's control and to be able to rule his kingdom as his own man.


Tags : The Greatest Traitor: The Life of Sir Roger Mortimer, Ruler of England 1327-1330 [IAN MORTIMER] on Amazon.com. *FREE* shipping on qualifying offers. Shipped from UK, please allow 10 to 21 business days for arrival. Fine, FIRST EDITION, JONATHAN CAPE,IAN MORTIMER,The Greatest Traitor: The Life of Sir Roger Mortimer, Ruler of England 1327-1330,JONATHAN CAPE,0224062492,England,United Kingdom, Great Britain,Biography,Death and burial,Edward,Isabella,Mortimer, Roger de,Political activity,c 1000 CE to c 1500,Biography: general,Biography: royalty,British & Irish history: c 1000 to c 1500

The Greatest Traitor The Life of Sir Roger Mortimer Ruler of England 13271330 IAN MORTIMER 9780224062497 Books Reviews

Illuminating factual history of a largely unknown historical figure. After reading ISABEAU and THE KING MUST DIE by N. Gemini Sasson, I felt that I needed to know more of Roger Mortimer and the turbulent times that he lived in. This book fills in with a great amount of detail concerning Roger and Isabella as well as Edward II and Edward III and also prominent nobility. Of great interest was the Berkeley Castle incident where Edward II supposedly was killed, but actually escaped. Highly recommended for anyone interested in English history.
This book has been an absolute treat to read. Yes there is a tremendous amount of information, names and places but it is rare to find a non fiction history book that is a real "page turner". It is good to know that there are great historians in the world that can refute years of propaganda but still remain faithful to facts and the times in which these people lived. I would shake your hand ,Sir.
Ian Mortimer writes excellent historical narratives and this is no exception. Given how intertwined Roger Mortimer is in English Medieval history it is good that a biography was completed as there seemed to be no lack of sources for the subject. I'm still a bit dubious on Mortimer's in-depth role in keeping Edward II alive, I believe it is fact that Edward did survive in the way described in the letter. Whether he was conned into believing this or he actually did escape, I have heard good arguments for both. Having heard Mortimer's theory in Edward III The Perfect King, reading it the second time does make it seem that Edward would need help. Fantastic book and if you are interested in high drama, this period of Medieval England is the most politically intriguing with all of the double dealings and of course the evil Hugh Despenser Younger. Great read! Highly recommended.
My, my. Didn't important folks have a hell of a life in those days. What runs through all accounts of that period is the sometime inexplicable behavior of men, but it was a result of being such a young population. Impulse and being quick to anger and fight accounted for so much. And it was not a time when any of these folks had any real though of what was good for the nation. It was entirely what benefited them and confounded their real or imagined enemies. What comes through in this book is how reasoned was Roger Mortimer's cold back-stabbing. I would urge you to contrast it with the same author's book, The Greatest Knight, for a view of how a principled man behaved and how being principled didn't make life any easier than the life of a traitor.
If you enjoy history, then this is the book to read. As an avid reader of medieval history, l had never heard of Roger Mortimer or his exploits. He was one of a very few that escaped the tower of london, deposed king Edward II, had an affair with the queen and ruled England for 3 years. His life was full of intrigue and tragedy. This book also goes in depth regarding what really happened to Edward II. Was he really murdered in such a grizzly manner or did he escape his captors and find solice in Italy? The book also discusses the many war campaigns that plagued 14th century. This was a devastating time period of traitors and intrigue but at the same time fascinating.
Not an easy read, but a joy nonetheless. I still have my freshman college British history text, and found Roger Mortimer mentioned only once, in his adulterous relationship with Queen Isabella, wife of Edward II. What a waste! It is difficult enough to understand those tumultuous times, but this author has brought them to life in great detail. I had already read "Edward III, The Perfect King", and so was well aware of the outcome of this book (should have read them in reverse order). I also tend to read the author's notes thoroughly, as they often contain additional helpful information. Had these two books been available in my college days, I can just imagine the wonderful classroom discussions we might have had.
Most of this work is very nuanced and insightful, as it demonstrates the fluctuations in the relationships between the nobility and Edward II, and that it was not simply a matter of all the lords lining up against Edward II and Gaveston or Edward II and Despenser. The author also presents a great deal of information about English rule I. Ireland in the 1310s and 1320s, a topic that is often glossed over in general discussions of this era in English history.

It loses its course somewhat from its discussion of the Berkeley Castle plot onward, however. While Mortimer presents an interesting case for Edward II's survival that cannot be readily disproven he assumes the ex-King survived based on hypotheticals and without sufficient substantiation, thus affecting his depiction of events from 1327 to 1330. His narrative of events is dependent on the ideas that Edward III knew Edward II survived before the trial of Lord Berkeley, that Edward III wanted vengeance for his father when there is no evidence of strong filial piety prior to joining Queen Isabella and Roger Mortimer in France, and the notion that Roger Mortimer and Isabella had a child when, in spite of the centuries of stories around their "great romance," when even the author presents no concrete evidence that they engaged in a physical relationship.

This is a worthwhile read, but one must be careful to account for the impact of the author's assumptions and interpretations on the overarching evidence-based narrative of the events of the life of Roger Mortimer. We cannot and should not dismiss these biases outright, but the events that occurred in 1327 to 1330 could reasonably have occurred without Edward II's survival, and Edward III's push for Roger Mortimer's end not out of wanting to avenge his father's death or out of the threat posed by his father's continued survival, but simply to be free of Roger's control and to be able to rule his kingdom as his own man.